Second-hand Shopping Guide: 5 Can't Miss Thrift Stores in New York City
Thrifting in New York City isn’t just about saving money, it’s about uncovering hidden gems, embracing your personal style, and finding fashion that feels one-of-a-kind. From curated vintage pieces to unexpected designer steals, the city’s secondhand scene is something you don’t want to miss. Whether you're on the hunt for a Y2K top, a vintage leather jacket, or a luxury handbag, NYC’s thrift stores have something for everyone. To get you started, here are five can’t-miss spots that offer some of the best thrifting the city has to offer.
Tired Thrift
📍10 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn NY 11222
Tired Thrift is anything but tired- it’s a favorite known for its quirky vibe, bold fashion, and super-curated selection. Think baby tees, cargo pants, and Y2K accessories that look straight out of a 2003 magazine spread. There’s always something new to discover, and everything feels intentional, but not overwhelming. Whether you're building your dream Pinterest wardrobe or just looking for a few standout pieces, Tired Thrift is a must-visit.
2. landline vintage
📍15 Essex St, New York, NY 10002
Landline Vintage blends the charm of a retro closet with the edge of NYC street style. The curated collection of 80s, 90s, and early 2000s pieces feel current but nostalgic. You’ll find structured blazers, slinky tanks, vintage denim, and accessories that pull it all together. It’s the perfect spot if you’re looking to add a little vintage polish to your everyday wardrobe or find a luxury piece for a fraction of the price.
3. Harley’s
📍41 Essex St, New York, NY 10002
Harley’s is the perfect place to shop for a grungy vintage look. With cool, edgy pieces like leather, cargo, mesh, and metallics, it’s a go-to for a wide range of styles. With prices ranging from $15-$225, you find unique pieces or even something from your favorite high-end brand. There are choices for every style and every budget. Best of all, their Instagram is updated often with new arrivals and certain pieces can be shopped on their Depop for those who can’t stop by their New York location.
4. Unearth vintage
📍159 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
If you are heading into Brooklyn, Unearth Vintage in Cobble Hill is your one-stop shop for fun and functional vintage pieces. Featuring everything from linen trousers and crochet tanks to chunky sweaters, colorful sets, and rare sneakers. It is the ideal place for anyone looking to build a vintage capsule wardrobe or just grab a few standout pieces. Unearth Vintage is an all around fun shopping experience even if you come home empty handed (which let’s be honest, you probably won’t).
5. The thrifty hog
📍40 W 25th St Front 2, New York, NY 10010
The Thrifty Hog is more than just a thrift store, it’s an enterprise supporting homeless mothers in NYC, so every purchase supports a great cause. Their inventory includes everything from luxury handbags and designer heels to everyday basics and home goods. If you’re after high-end thrifting without the high-end prices, this is the spot. The space is full of can’t miss pieces that do so much more than just boost your closet.
